You all saw GRAZIA magazine burst onto the women’s magazine scene with plenty of fanfare.

Who among us gave in to the temptation to buy it at least once, maybe more, just to see what it was like?

Me!

So, after a few weeks of reading them side by side, I decided to conduct a proper study so we could make a proper decision: to choose or not to choose?!

You’ll forgive me for doing all this painstaking research with last week’s issues. I was on vacation, after all…

So let’s start at the beginning…

THE COVER—or, more precisely, the front cover

Article photoArticle photo

ELLE appears in deep red over a photo of a gorgeous young woman who’s beautiful and sexy but still elegant and stylish: Megan FOX. The accompanying cover line is tucked discreetly into the lower right corner: “Will MEGAN FOX dethrone Angenina Jolie?”

GRAZIA, in hot pink, goes for a more “visual,” provocative approach: LINDSAY LOHAN in a minidress, with bleached-blond hair and black nail polish, and a more tabloid-style cover line: “The LINDSAY LOHAN controversy shakes up the fashion world”

But when you think about it, these are two very similar stories: two women everyone’s talking about, one elegant, the other scandalous.

The similarities don’t stop there. Take the cover design, for example: both play up the price, or more specifically, the price CUT, one rather “discreetly” (“new price €2”), the other much more conspicuously, with the old price crossed out and the new one in plain sight: €1.

Now let’s look at the headlines: there are two that match, almost word for word!

Article photoArticle photo

Before we take a closer look at how the two magazines cover this topic, let’s carry on with our almost scientific analysis by looking at the overall structure of both magazines and the kinds of stories they run.

So let’s flip past seven pages of ADS in ELLE and five in GRAZIA to get to the table of contents, the second major piece of the layout after the cover:

THE TABLE OF CONTENTS

Article photoArticle photo

Of course, you’ve probably noticed that I’ve been putting ELLE first since the beginning of this study… And yes, I have to admit I have a soft spot for this magazine. It’s part of our shared heritage!

Still, looking at these two pictures, I have to face facts: I prefer GRAZIA’s table of contents. It’s easier to read, divided into four clearly defined sections, with easy-to-read fonts and color coding you get at a glance!

As for the content itself, they’re clearly taking the same approach:

NEWS for ELLE / CURRENT EVENTS for GRAZIA

STYLEELLE / FASHION for GRAZIA, both rounding up shopping ideas, looks, and news

THE feature: LOVE for ELLE, BEAUTY for GRAZIA. That said, GRAZIA doesn’t leave LOVE out either: there’s a story on “LOVE HOTELS”

LIFESTYLE for GRAZIA / the same stuff scattered throughout ELLE: travel, decor, cooking, horoscopes, etc.

That said, the Paris edition of ELLE does have a must for “the parisienne”: ELLEPARIS, which doesn’t even show up in the table of contents!

Next comes the editorial:

EDITORIAL

Article photoArticle photo

Here, ELLE clearly stands out: there’s substance, there are values—feminism, in this case—and it all gets a page of its own, as befits a current affairs magazine… for women. Meanwhile, GRAZIA gives us a few words about putting together this special beauty issue, squeezed between the edge of the page and a visual rundown of what’s inside.

Let’s keep going to get a clearer picture:

In GRAZIA, wordplay is something of a trademark

Article photo

Pretty fun, even if the articles themselves aren’t really my cup of tea…!

Then comes the news. At first glance, I’d say GRAZIA leans more toward the sensational, with stories on Ben Laden’s family,  the Courjault case, and the movie being filmed about it. But then what are we supposed to make of ELLEinfoHEBDOphénomène’s “Panties on the Run”? Or the  elleinfohebdo piece on the trench coat and who’ll wear it best?

Examples

Article photo

Article photoArticle photo

So when I see a pretty in-depth interview with Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet and an article on abortion in FRANCE that also touches on the situation in Spain, all in GRAZIA, I think that stacks up pretty well against the quarter page ELLE devotes to abortion in Spain, especially since most of it is a photo!

Article photo

Article photo Article photo

Article photo

And what about FASHION, you ask?

Well, here are a few pictures from both magazines, and I dare you to guess which ones came from which!

Article photo  PHOTO 1:  ELLE or GRAZIA?

PHOTO 2: GRAZIA or ELLE? Article photo

PHOTOS 3 and 4?

Article photo Article photo

And finally, PHOTOS 5 AND 6?

Article photo Article photo

So, to wrap up, I can already tell you that this week’s ELLE answers last week’s GRAZIA with a “What’s New in Beauty” feature that echoes its “Beauty Special”;

I can also tell you that last week ELLE mentioned Jean Sarkozy in its elleinfopsychologycelebrity section, to which this week’s GRAZIA fires back with “SARKOZY: Which Brother Is Your Favorite?” featuring Jean and Pierre.

And finally, while GRAZIA is holding steady at €1, ELLE has gone back up to €2.50, as discreetly as ever!

In the end, ELLE will always have its recipe cards and its indispensable Paris addresses, but I think GRAZIA isn’t done surprising us. It’s already giving us much more to read than I would have expected from its slightly flashier look…

What about you? Have you made up your mind?