For the first time, the Coen brothers delve into their Jewish past and their most personal experiences with religion, like preparing for a bar mitzvah. And in taking on something that touched them to the core, I think they lose some of their usual flair.
So instead of the gonzo movies they’ve gotten us used to, the ones that break new cinematic ground at every turn, I felt like I was watching a movie that was just plain “predictable”;
so our hero, Larry Gopnik, suddenly has to deal with a string of personal crises: his wife suddenly wants to leave him, a student keeps after him for a grade that won’t jeopardize his scholarship, a mail-order company won’t leave him alone, there’s a car accident, and it all comes at him one thing after another, faster than he can cope;
he looks for answers from rabbis who do nothing but turn his questions back on him, and tries to stay on the straight and narrow, to be the “serious man” who’ll set things right, with no luck whatsoever.
He lets himself get played by his kids, his brother, and even his wife’s lover, without doing anything to change the course of his life or make it any better.
So what are the Coen brothers telling us in this movie? “Jews ask questions”? That goes without saying! “Life is absurd”? We’ve seen that one before! “We’re all going to die”? Nothing revolutionary there!
When it comes to this sort of thing, Woody Allen in his heyday—when was that again?!—was the best, and always will be!
So, dear Coen brothers, I suppose you had to make a movie about this to face your demons, or at least some of them? Well, now you’ve done it, so please move on, so we can have you back as the directors worthy of “O Brother,” “Fargo,” and “Barton Fink”… Unless age, illness, and the suddenly more real prospect of death have gotten the better of that freshness of yours and the sheer glee you’ve used and abused in every movie you’ve made up to now!




