The Women on the 6th Floor: a promising movie with a terrific cast… But what else?

Acting: Article photoArticle photoArticle photo Screenplay: Article photo

The movie takes place in the 1960s, before the upheaval of ’68, in a bourgeois world where women’s days revolve around major events like a pedicure appointment, a game of bridge, or a parish charity sale. The men occupy themselves with highly intellectual pursuits, talk stocks, and cheat on their wives, all in a dreary, dusty atmosphere.

But here’s the thing: on the sixth floor of the building where the Jouberts have lived for generations—Fabrice Luchini and Sandrine Kiberlain (editor’s note: spotted in Deauville this weekend, by the way!)—up on the sixth floor, then, live the Spanish maids. These women left everything behind to come work for these uptight bourgeois families, and they do it without ever complaining, always with a smile, finding something to be happy about in the tiniest moments of everyday life. I mean, I’m happy to vacuum while singing and swaying my hips as gracefully as they do, but for five minutes, not day after day from 6am to 11pm!

So at the top of the building, there’s joie de vivre, simple pleasures, smiles, and delicious little dishes, with the women all looking out for one another. A few floors down: pettiness, fake friendships, and above all… boredom, deep, deep boredom.

So there you have it: I’ve set the scene and summed up the story. I’ll add that there’s an excellent cast:

Fabrice Luchini (he does his usual Luchini thing, so you either love it or hate it—I love it!), Sandrine Kiberlain, perfectly at home as a country girl who’s managed to marry well and slips easily into the role of a proper little Parisian bourgeois wife, and then those wonderful Spanish actresses, including Carmen Maura, whom you may have seen in Volver, among other films, and Natalia Verbeke, the Argentine actress who plays Maria, the Jouberts’ maid.

Well then, you might say, all the ingredients are there for a little gem, with finely drawn characters, laughs, and emotion…

Well, I’m sorry to say it: it doesn’t come together, not at all!

Yes, I smiled and even laughed; yes, I let myself get carried away by the music of that wonderful language, Spanish; and yes, I felt the warmth that Carmen Maura and her fellow actresses radiate, as they always do.

But even the best actors in the world can’t save a movie with a nonexistent script. And that’s exactly the problem: the screenplay is supposed to be the backbone of a good movie, and this one can’t hold up a film that otherwise has so much going for it.

Why does Joubert, a dull stockbroker stuck in his daily rut, suddenly take an interest in the lives of the women upstairs and turn into this bighearted man, like a butterfly emerging from its chrysalis? We don’t know, and we never will. Why does he suddenly decide to go against his peers and help these invisible women without worrying about what people will say? We don’t know that either. So, you might say, what does it matter as long as you have a good time? Well… no! Because you never really connect with any of the characters. And the story wavers between light farce and a character study of a man who, and I quote, “feels free for the first time in his life.”

So, to wrap up, you’ve probably guessed by now: a big disappointment. I’ve already just about forgotten the movie because I never felt drawn into it!

What about you? Have you seen it? Did you like it?

See you on Hellocoton!