We’re very loyal Air France customers. We’ve flown with them for years, for work and for pleasure, sometimes by choice and sometimes because there was no alternative. And quite frankly, I have to say I’ve found myself grumbling more than once over the past few months, thanks to various things going wrong, some of them every single time.

A far cry from the serenity of this beautiful image…

And this summer, when we booked a round-trip ticket, again through Air France, we got to try another airline in the sky team alliance, Delta Airlines.

Air France on the way out, Delta on the way back, and suddenly it all made sense:

take the best of both airlines and the perfect flight might actually be possible!

Because while Air France has room to improve its service, Delta gets things done. As for the fleet and the quality of the planes, well, Delta really ought to invest in some 21st-century models!

So here’s how the two actually stacked up:

The planes

On the way out, then, Air France. An Airbus 380, with seats that were more comfortable than any I’ve had in economy, plus champagne and a gourmet menu to boot! And of course, a personal screen and a great selection of movies: new releases, classics, comedies, tearjerkers. In short, everything you need for a smooth flight.

On the way back, though, it was still an Air France ticket, but the flight was on Delta Airlines. A Boeing, very clearly from the last century, judging by the color and material of the seats: a positively stunning faux leather in a blue that had faded with age. As for modern technology, there were a few screens scattered around the cabin showing old TV series that must have been bought by the pound! And the seats? Even though we paid extra at the last minute to make sure we had enough legroom, the seat cushions were too short and there were no footrests, so aside from the decent legroom…

In the contest for planes and onboard amenities: Air France 1 – Delta 0!

Now let’s move on to what, for me, has always been the make-or-break factor, the thing that can make an experience wonderful or ruin it:

Service

Over the past few months, and on this latest round trip in particular, we’ve had to use several services from Air France and Delta.

Here they are, in no particular order: assistance for unaccompanied minors, a wheelchair, and a special seating request for a child on crutches who couldn’t bend their leg.

The result? For unaccompanied minors, which we only tried with Air France, the service is MANDATORY and COSTS EXTRA for children under 12, and it was an organizational disaster every single time. So yes, in the end, the child does get on the plane! That’s something! But every time, I’m absolutely convinced it’s down to sheer luck! Why? Because not one person we talk to can tell us when someone will come for the child. Usually we hear, “In fifteen minutes,” or “In twenty minutes,” or “It depends!” No list of the unaccompanied minors by name. No concrete information, just vague answers and guesswork! And we’re entrusting them with our own children! Our suitcases are better identified, numbered, and tracked.

Then there’s the wheelchair request: with Air France, what a saga! We put in the request 48 hours ahead of time, and when we got to the Air France counter: nothing. I ask about it and I’m told, “I’ll take care of it, I’ll send a Telex!” Yes, really, a telex! If any of you are old enough to know what that is, feel free to raise your hand! Anyway, I don’t know if we can blame the time it took for said telex to get through, but half an hour and two reminders later, still no wheelchair! It did finally show up too, but what a hassle!

At the Delta counter, on the other hand, the wheelchair materialized faster than we could ask for it! And we hadn’t even requested one in advance! Delta also took care of notifying the arrival airport so that a wheelchair would be waiting for us as we got off the plane! Not a single tweet or hysterical threat from me!

Finally, the request for accessible seating: Air France tells you to call a dedicated number, and here’s the answer you get: “There are seats the ground staff can assign at the gate when you board, but there’s nothing else we can do! Get there early and ask, and you’ll see if it’s possible!” Does that make sense to you? Well, it doesn’t to me!

So on the way back, we didn’t want to take any chances. We couldn’t book any of the handful of extra-legroom economy seats online, so we paid extra for the whole family to get what turned out to be only marginally more comfort!

So, to sum up, quality of service: Air France 0 – Delta 1 potentially (we only actually tested one service).

There you have it, my end-of-vacation post! A vacation that, otherwise, was absolutely wonderful!

But I’ve tweeted all I can tweet about what went wrong, and I can see that the Air France agents I dealt with genuinely wanted to help. I’ve come to the conclusion that the procedures they have in place simply can’t work, so now that vacation’s over, I’ve decided to share my experience with you and dream a little!

And now I’m speaking directly to Air France, the airline I booked with, and here’s what I have to say:

I dream of the day when I can rave about the quality of every service and the overall experience, whether I’m flying Air France or any other airline Air France chooses to put me on!

I dream of the day when I can ask a question and get a clear, straightforward, reassuring answer that’s the same every time.

I dream of not having to pay an extra €300 to make sure a child with a temporary disability has a basic level of comfort, only to realize pretty quickly that most of those seats had simply been handed out to economy passengers because of overbooking, based on who knows what!

I dream of consistent rules when you book your tickets through Air France: on the way out, five suitcases, two of which can weigh up to 32 kg thanks to Flying Blue gold status, and on the way back, six bags, but each with a 25 kg limit, and an instant $75 charge because one suitcase is 4 kg over! Talk about squaring the circle, right?

I dream of Air France taking a cue from the other Sky Team airlines on how to deliver efficient service, or finding a whole new way to do it.

I dream of Air France doing more for its customers with disabilities, whether temporary or permanent!

I dream, I dream… But since when do dreams come true?!

And you, what’s your favorite airline?