The Broken Arm or Café Pinson

And Merci in spirit.

You’ve all heard of these two spots if you keep up with what’s trendy in Paris in general, and in the haut Marais in particular.

I hadn’t had a chance to check either of them out, so I killed two birds with one stone.

The verdict didn’t exactly surprise me.

Let’s start with The Broken Arm: it’s a little out of the way, on the edge of the Haut Marais, and you can feel the buzz of place de la Republique just around the corner. You stumble across the storefront by chance, the entrance is just as unassuming, and you really have to look for the sign bearing the name that’s on the lips of every hip Parisian.

broken arm
broken arm

As I push open the door, I feel a bit like I’m walking into someone’s home without having been invited …

Ahhh, Merci, where are you …?

It’s like an icy draft … The merchandise, clearly picked by someone with an eye for what’s in right now, sits on display like museum pieces behind an invisible velvet rope. 

A quick trip downstairs: I could swear I was in one of the temples of fashion on rue Saint Honoré. Sharply tailored, fashion-forward clothes by designers whose names are new to me, like Otswald Helgason, Jacquemus, and Cédric Charlier. 

Article photo

Article photo

And then there are some more familiar labels, but with one-of-a-kind pieces like these featherlight pink woven Nike sneakers.

Woven NIKE sneakers
Woven NIKE sneakers

Inside the concept store, a door leads straight to the “cafeteria” …

A cafeteria, yes, but without the buzz of conversation that makes a place feel warm and alive. No, it’s more like a bunch of kids sitting alone in detention, each with a tin of sardines in front of them. Yes, really, a tin of sardines. The “selection” on the menu was so limited and unappealing that, after racing to grab the last free table—and it was barely noon!—we got up and left.

As we step outside, that icy, almost oppressive feeling lifts, and we can breathe again.

Which way to Merci?

So off we go to café Pinson, just a few steps away.

café Pinson storefront
café Pinson storefront

Here, we barely make it through the door before we’re greeted with a warm smile. The customers already at their tables are comfortably settled in and look right at home, clearly planning to stay for a good few hours. And no wonder: the place feels cozy, and the food is clearly fresh and natural.

café PINSON
café PINSON

We sink into two big armchairs, and there’s another smile as the server hands us the menu.

The choices are fairly limited: two salads, the soup of the day, two vegetarian dishes, and a list of desserts, all organic, wheat-free, and gluten-free.

café Pinson menu
café Pinson menu

It’s all very tasty, but it’s still a quick bite, and it’s not going to satisfy anyone with a big appetite. But with summer around the corner—yes, really—it feels good to eat fresh food made on-site, with thoughtfully chosen flavors that go beautifully together.

café Pinson salad
café Pinson salad
Another salad at Pinson
Another salad at Pinson

Big disappointment: the lemon tart was so pretty, but the crust was so hard I couldn’t finish it. I should’ve asked: tart crust without wheat just doesn’t work!

Merci, where are my desserts, my moelleux au chocolat and my crumble?

café Pinson lemon tart
café Pinson lemon tart

And there you have it.

So what’s the verdict after trying both places?

I couldn’t stop thinking about Merci. Everything about these two places reminds me of the shop that started it all, the one that brought these out-of-the-way streets to life.

“The Broken Arm” is missing a soul, and at “café Pinson,” the food doesn’t quite live up to the warmth of the welcome or the coziness of the place …

What can I say?

Merci, Merci, I want my giant salad, the smiles, the variety, the light pouring through the glass roof, the little notebooks, the wraps, and the ethically sourced goods!

And the little FIAT500 that’s always there to greet me, so warm and cheeky!

Article photo

café Pinson

6 Rue du Forez  75003 Paris
09 83 82 53 53

The Broken Arm

 12, rue Perrée 75003 Paris

Merci

111 Boulevard Beaumarchais 75003 Paris