July 15, 2015 Update
This restaurant is no longer in business. It’s closed its doors. If I may be so bold, I’d say being trendy can only get you so far, and this closure is probably a case in point.
Le Sergent Recruteur.
41 Rue Saint-Louis en l'Île, 75004 Paris
Phone: 01 43 54 75 42
service
value for money
And yet it had all started so well...
Okay, fine, I’d booked that very day for dinner, so all I could get were seats at the bar, on high stools. But really, I told myself, wasn’t the main thing that I finally got to try this restaurant I’d heard so much about, right here on MY island, no less?

So there we are, settled in at the bar. Someone comes over to explain the concept: a tasting menu built around fresh, natural ingredients harvested on the farm in Normandy that grows the restaurant’s vegetables, plus good seafood straight from our beautiful French coast. The dining room is empty, and the staff couldn’t be more attentive... That won’t last.
First surprise: someone rattles off the 8 or 10 dishes we’re about to try. Of course, he tells us that if there’s anything we don’t want, we just have to say so. But there’s no printed menu, just a quick rundown with very little detail. And the lineup is going to change, though we don’t know that yet!
And the food starts coming.
Now, I’ll admit it: I’m not a fan of tasting 10 different dishes without any say in the matter, at the mercy of an all-powerful chef. But what if every bite, every portion, however tiny, sent me into fits of culinary ecstasy and had me swinging from the curtains? You never know, it could be a pleasant surprise... Or not!
First things first: Le Sergent Recruteur doesn’t quite live up to its name. It could use a new one that makes the Japanese influence clear. When the chef feels an irresistible urge to slip sake, yuzu, and other Japanese flavors into every dish, you’re better off knowing up front!
Back to the dishes: one of them was supposed to be pan-seared foie gras, my guilty pleasure. But dish after dish went by, and still no foie gras. When dessert rolls around and I ask the person who’d promised it to us, he explains that yes, the chef sometimes decides to make changes entirely on his own. And that’s how our foie gras ended up being replaced by sea urchin!
And that’s where I say no! What’s the point of asking if there’s anything we don’t want if you’re just going to swap dishes without so much as a word?!
As for the rest, if I had to sum up the meal, I’d say it was complicated and fussy above all else.
When I eat at this kind of restaurant, I find myself thinking the chef has missed the whole point: the simple pleasure of eating. The kind of pleasure where a single bite leaves you so deeply satisfied that it takes you back to your happiest food memories, or makes a new one.
The pleasure of discovering those gorgeous, delicious, top-quality ingredients that speak for themselves when you keep things simple.
To be completely fair, I have to say it almost happened with the “variations on fall cabbages, praline vinaigrette.” That one was almost up there with Passard and his vegetable symphonies.
I wish we could forget all this intellectual masturbation, fine-dining edition, and get back to what matters: simple dishes and ingredients that let you rediscover flavors without drowning them in whatever exotic touch happens to be fashionable.
So here, in no particular order, are the grandiose dish names and descriptions we heard over those interminable two and a half hours. I’m afraid my back, and the rest of me for that matter, will be making me pay for a few days for perching on that fancy stool we were given.
- Amuse-bouche
- Duck rillette and red onion, carrot-ginger juice, pumpkin soup
- House-made bread and butter, vegetables from a woman in Normandy
- Sole from saint gille croix de vie
- Low-temperature egg, tangy cream and golden caviar (so low it's raw)
- Lobster and multicolored beet salad
- Sea urchin, yuzu, shawamoushi (?)
- Variations on fall cabbages with praline and yuzu vinaigrette
- Sole with veal consommé
- Sarthe hen with vin jaune emulsion and black truffle
And a few pictures to show you what I mean.
As for the bill, it was decidedly tastier than anything we ate! €150 per person.
That’ll teach me to try to keep up with Parisian dining trends.
What I’ll take away from this experience is that what matters is enjoying yourself and sharing a good time. A lot goes into that, from the atmosphere to the quality of the food to a smile from the staff. Of all those ingredients, the smile was the only one we got, and it wasn’t enough.






