Toni Erdmann 

All right, let’s cut the Cannes jury some slack. 

First of all, I haven’t seen the films that won yet, and they probably deserve their awards.

Second, it’s true there’s something disorienting about Toni Erdmann. You can see how the distinguished members of the jury, having spent whole days immersed in powerful works tackling the weighty social and geopolitical issues of our time, might have overlooked the slightly worn-out theme of Maren Ade’s film: the meaning of life! A little lightweight for a Palme, I suppose… 

And then there’s all the laughing, and not the quiet, philosophical kind, either: more the kind you get from juvenile gags like glasses with cat whiskers, wigs, and fake teeth. I won’t say any more and spoil the fun. It probably gives those smile muscles more of a workout than a Cannes prizewinner is supposed to.

Above all, this film is a UFO… or rather a UCO, an unidentified cinematic object. It defies classification, refuses to fit in any box: neither drama nor comedy, neither philosophical fable nor social satire, and a little bit of all four at once.

In any case, Georges Miller and his sidekicks didn’t take to it, and in doing so, they may have done the German director’s film a huge favor. Freed from the symbolic weight of a Cannes award, Tony Erdmann is a film you can go into lightheartedly, without pretension or that intimidating “masterpiece” stamp.

So you can laugh out loud, or get bored, or feel for this brilliant consultant who’s completely lost in life; you can find her worried father ridiculous or wonderful, get swept up in this slightly mad whirlwind where you meet all sorts of characters who verge on caricature, or wonder about the contrast between these real people who seem so fake and the sincerity, the truth that comes through in the one who puts on makeup and plays dress-up. 

In the end, it doesn’t really matter, because once you’ve left the dark theater, that tired little question slowly settles in, maybe without you even noticing. What makes life worth living?

So for a moment you put the day’s supposedly big social questions out of your mind and think how nice it is when a film talks to us about what really matters.

Article by c lui