Costume jewelry is booming, especially now that gold prices have skyrocketed over the past few years. An impulse buy, a little gift we let ourselves have when we want a fleeting thrill at a price we can afford. New brands have popped up, each more tempting than the last. But does that mean we have to give in? Pretend that buying this kind of thing has no impact on the world around us?

Louyetu — the first

There was the Louyetu scandal. Suddenly we found out that the much-touted “made in Paris” amounted to simply assembling parts that did, in fact, come from China. Accounts from former employees came pouring in as people began to speak out. All against a backdrop of employee mistreatment. It was as if Louyetu had suddenly become the poster child for the worst of startup culture and unchecked consumerism. And then, as so often happens in a world where we’re always flicking to the next thing, one scandal pushes another out of the headlines. Sure, Louyetu lost a few tens of thousands of followers on Instagram, but beyond that? Hard to say, isn’t it? Has the flagship store on rue Volney been any less crowded since those revelations? I don’t think so! Life went back to normal, and Louyetu is still very good at telling its own story. And life goes on… Just goes to show how quickly outrage fades when there’s something we want.

Purelei

Article photo

I admit I fell for the design of Purelei’s jewelry. All of a sudden, it was all over the posts of the fashion influencers I’ve followed for years, and I admit, I was tempted. But this time, after getting burned by the Louyetu experience, I decided to dig a little deeper. The photos on the website are gorgeous. The jewelry comes in three shades of gold: yellow, white, and rose. You can browse by type of jewelry, by trend, or by collection. But good luck finding out where the jewelry comes from. Where is it made? A mystery! So I got in touch with customer service. The first thing they told me: it’s designed in Germany. It took several follow-ups before I finally got an answer: everything is made in China. Really, why was I surprised? There’s no way jewelry like this could have been made in Europe at those prices. No surprise, really, just something obvious we so often go out of our way not to face.

Zag — the cherry on top

Article photo

ZAG jewelry is made of stainless steel. You’ll find it in every concept store and multibrand boutique that sells trendy, affordable jewelry. Since stainless steel isn’t a precious metal, you might have thought it came from a European factory. But here’s the thing: the brand is upfront about where it’s made. And this is the first time I’ve ever seen a brand tout its jewelry as “handcrafted… in China”! Now there’s a way to put two unlikely things together just so you can use the word “craftsmanship.” And insult everyone who can genuinely lay claim to it in the process.

The question remains: have we given in? Are we going to let our impulses and whims, however fleeting, call the shots even when we know better? That long necklace that goes perfectly with the little black dress we just bought, those little rings we can’t stop buying, those bracelets with stones that supposedly have calming powers: do we really need them? Couldn’t we do without them? And in doing so, couldn’t we do our bit to rein in the shopping frenzy that’s made us blindly complicit in shameful production practices?