It took me a long time, a very long time, to finally decide to visit what all of Paris is calling the new temple of contemporary art. Well, I went. I won’t be going back anytime soon.

Bourse du commerce – The History

We can thank François Pinault. The Bourse du Commerce, which had been languishing in the shabby trappings of its old life as a commodities exchange, has finally come back to life. And we can marvel at how beautiful it is. The glass roof that soars forty meters overhead.

Article photo

The dome and its extraordinary mural, whose five artists divided up the 140 meters between them to celebrate the rise of capitalism. The ironwork on the interior balconies.

Article photo

Camus de Mézières’s double-helix staircase, which made it easier to move sacks of grain in and out of storage. The machinery room in the basement. In short, this showcase of Parisian architecture from the 16th to the 19th century deserved to shine again. It just needed a new purpose… and quite a bit of money. As luck would have it, the fabulously wealthy François Pinault was looking for somewhere to show what he’d amassed over six decades of collecting contemporary art… and no doubt also to answer his counterpart Bernard Arnault in kind, with a venue to rival his foundation in the bois de Boulogne.

Bourse du commerce – Contemporary Art?

A contemporary art museum it was, then! But simply restoring this historic building wouldn’t do. It needed an “architectural gesture.” So they called in Tadao Ando… and poured concrete. An enormous concrete cylinder was built inside the building. Luckily, you can’t see it from outside. This made the space “conducive,” as the explanatory panels put it, to displaying works of art from our own time. And here’s where I risk drawing the ire of many admirers and theorists of modernity. Because let’s be clear: the art is just as impenetrable as the concrete! If there’s one thing you can give this place credit for, it’s consistency.

The galleries are filled with one conceptual work after another, most of them not the least bit interested in beauty, and all with one thing in common: you need an explanation to make sense of them.

You’ll find that explanation in the museum’s wall labels, the writing of which is a work of art in itself.

Article photo

Or you can listen to the museum educators, who cheerfully explain the rarely obvious connections between the works and patriarchal domination, the fluidity of water and matter, and the light that illuminates the world.

Article photoI could go on. But I can’t resist mentioning this monumental work made of light bulbs, which the label explains can be installed with the bulbs on or off. Well, that changes everything!

Bourse du commerce – A Second of Eternity?

So of course, for one second of eternity, you think you must not be smart enough to grasp these heights of artistic achievement.

Article photo

And then you look up again at the dome, the corbels, the delicate details of the balconies.

Article photo

You pass a window and admire the view of the surrounding Paris buildings, and decide never to put yourself down like that again.

Just because some contemporary art has decided to look down its nose at us doesn’t make us stupid. We’re allowed to find it all pretentious and often ugly. This beautiful setting deserved so much better.

Bourse du commerce 2 Rue de Viarmes, 75001 Paris

P.S. I agree 100%, but this piece was written by Clui, who went with me.