The Galeries Lafayette Christmas tree is in the hot seat. Ever since the official unveiling, the criticism has been pouring in, and glowing reviews of this year’s tree are few and far between. You have to understand: the Galeries Lafayette tree is the most eagerly awaited attraction in Paris when it comes to kicking off the holiday season. Especially this year, which marks the 50th anniversary of the tradition!

Article photo


So this year, the department store handed fashion designer Jean Charles de Castelbajac the job of wowing every visitor. The result is unmistakably him: colorful, very colorful… 

Before making up my mind, I decided to take a good, hard look at the tree from every angle.


Article photo


Let’s start with the overall impression: the moment you walk in under the dome, there it is, right in front of you. You can’t miss it. It’s not so much the size that catches your eye as the sheer riot of color. Let’s be clear: I’m generally all for bright, cheerful colors. I’m a fan of JC/DC’s pop-inspired coats and outfits that brighten up everyday life. But here, it felt like someone had gone overboard in entirely the wrong place: as if an overexcited kid had raided the Stabilo stash and gone wild drawing what might be a fir tree. A Christmas tree? The jury’s still out…

So what we have here is a 3D drawing, in cardboard, with some cutouts thrown in. The thing is, not everyone can be Matisse. 


Article photo


When I looked more closely at what was supposed to be the branches of this majestic tree, whether a Nordmann fir or a spruce, I  saw nothing but rough scissor cuts. If it had been put up anywhere else, I’m not sure I’d have known what I was looking at.

Let’s keep looking, bearing in mind what this work is meant to be: a Christmas tree. So it should be all about magic and wonder, lights and sparkle, right? Not to mention the presents, the joy on children’s faces when they first see it, and the decorations on every branch!

So I looked it over, pulled it apart in my head, and took it in from every angle, from every balcony in this gorgeous building… What did I find? Nothing!

Article photo


As for lighting, there are barely one or two strips of energy-saving LEDs zigzagging around the tree or along the pieces of cardboard, and they switch on at set times. Spoiler alert: you can get lavish, dazzling string lights that save energy  too! 

Decorations, Christmas baubles, snowflakes, and other ornaments: don’t bother looking. There aren’t any! Unless those two or three blobs of color are supposed to be them? 

As for presents, not a single one. An original choice, or a cheeky wink from one of Paris’s temples of consumerism?

But what’s missing most of all is the feeling: the way people’s eyes light up and the dreams that come with this special time of year…

Watching people walk by, all I saw were doubtful looks and incredulous faces. They seemed to be wondering the same thing I was: where on earth did the Christmas magic go?!