I read the news yesterday, took a stroll around the place du Tertre today, and now I’m opening up the debate:

Starbucks might replace a historic brasserie on the place du Tertre:

Are you FOR it or AGAINST it?!

No sooner had I asked than the replies came flying in: all against, except for one, and I want to give a shout-out to the person who had the guts to take a different stand: @mamzellecarnetO!

And now it’s my turn to say what I think!

The place du Tertre … The quintessential Paris postcard. A charming little square lined with oh-so-Parisian brasseries and cafés. Painters and artists tirelessly painting our beautiful city again and again, and busy sketching tourists eager to take home a portrait!

I have to admit, when I read this bit of hot news—that Starbucks was moving in right in the heart of this oh-so-Parisian little village—my first reaction was mixed:

What?! Is the big bad American going to destroy another piece of our heritage, put a small business out of the picture, and kill the soul of our beautiful city?!

But when you really think about it, how authentic are the brasseries lining this pretty little square?

How good is the food they serve …? And as for the service … isn’t there some room for improvement there?

Do you ever see anyone but tourists there? Parisians have long since retreated to nearby neighborhoods that the hordes of foreign visitors overlook and where you can still find the real thing—Les Abbesses, for instance …

And anyway, haven’t we already committed—or at least considered—the sacrilege of opening a Ladurée on Fifth Avenue in New York?

But here’s the thing … This morning I went for a walk around Montmartre …

And I asked this gentleman, who works at “chez Eugène,” what he thought about the new chain moving in.

He answered with passion, even a little emotion! He told us about the brasserie, which was shut down over hygiene issues and is being sold to the highest bidder. And he painted a picture of future customers wandering around with coffee in a paper cup … and a muffin!

That last image did it for me! I’m not necessarily in favor of digging in our heels against all change, but I still think some places need to keep that Parisian touch that makes them what they are, and the place du Tertre is definitely one of them!

So, just like: 

@Whiskatze @emanu124 @Bullesdeflo @Parisinabottle @tylemeray @MonChasseur @MontmartAddict @ArianeGrumbach  @VMalamitsas @adrienGombeaud  @jadamned @berniecassel  @MariannePelissi @ParisienneNord @ParisienneT

I say no! What about you??